A collection of oral histories that reveal the loss of cultural continuity, identity, shifts in family responsibilities, gender roles and fractured relationships between generations that are just some of the challenges people face as they attempt to rebuild lives and communities. Displacement, resettlement, rehabilitation, reparation and. The views, conclusions, and recommendations in the working paper are not to be taken to represent the views of the commission. From a human rights perspective, involuntary resettlement may constitute forced eviction. Vivid firsthand accounts by the displaced themselves, gathered by. The complementarity of human rights and development approaches in the area of internal displacement. The human cost of development and resettlement paperback. Vivid firsthand accounts by the displaced themselves, gathered by panos london and partners in africa and asia.
The developer or investor shall include the costs of resettlement and compensation in the presentation of project costs and benefits. Human rightsbased approach needed to help resettle. This paper presents the case for a national policy on resettlement and rehabilitation. Chris mcdowell although displacement is commonly associated with refugees fleeing conflict, millions of people are resettled every year in the name of development and progress. Authors olivia bennett and christopher mcdowell use individual stories collected between 1997 and 2003 to convey the suffering caused by developmentcreated involuntary resettlement in kenya, botswana, namibia, lesotho, india, and pakistan. A collection of oral histories that reveal the loss of cultural continuity, identity, shifts in family responsibilities, gender roles and fractured relationships between. Development displacement population, in turn, is the single largest category among all internally displaced populations idp. Displaced people of mega development projects may find it difficult to adapt and reestablish themselves in the host community and, as a consequence, feel marginalized and discriminated against from political, economic, and cultural perspectives. A powerful book that seeks to address the absence of voice in the resettlement debate, it draws upon an extensive archive of vivid firsthand accounts by the displaced themselves, gathered. And while it focuses on the voices of the displaced, it also benefits from the contributions of dr christopher mcdowell of londons city university, who has been central to the continuing research and debate on developmentinduced displacement. The human cost of development routledge contemporary south asia series hari mohan mathur on amazon.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading displaced. In may 2012 a new phase of the project took place with the publication of displaced. Land acquisition and compensation in involuntary resettlement. Carlos zetter, roger, assessing the impacts and costs of forced displacement, vols. Pdf hari mohan mathur, displacement and resettlement in india.
The causes, consequences, and challenges of developmentinduced displacement by w. Susanna price and jane singer have assembled an amazing set of papers focused on country frameworks for displacement and resettlement. Improving outcomes in developmentinduced displacement and. Human rightsbased approach needed to help resettle displaced. These notions are reflective in the book displaced. Displaced is a valuable addition to the body of literature on developmentinduced displacement and resettlement didr, especially given the. Land acquisition and compensation are only two important issues as well. Hari mohan mathur is visiting professor at the council for social development, new delhi. Displacement, resettlement, rehabilitation, reparation, and. At the core of the problems plaguing dfdr are the technocratic and managerialist approaches to displacement and resettlement. As we can see, authorities who implement resettlement plans to ensure that such entitlements are provided to the displaced persons adequately and promptly, often do not have institutional capacity and a strategy to realise them. Displaced is a valuable addition to the body of literature on development induced displacement and resettlement didr, especially given the limited number of studies which have been published in this area over the past decade.
Displaced the human cost of development and resettlement. Developmentinduced displacement and resettlement didr occurs when people are forced to. The human cost of development and resettlement, palgrave we had our own culture and customs. With 15 million people estimated to be displaced by development construction each year cernea in bennett and mcdowell 2012.
Who pays for countering the resettlement effect in mininginduced displacements and resettlements. What can we learn from the practice of developmentforced. Development induced displacement and resettlement didr occurs when people are forced to leave their homes andor land as a result of development. Those affected are usually given financial compensation, which has. Mar 18, 20 these notions are reflective in the book displaced. Dams, displacement and the human cost of development. In the past ten years or so, displacement by development projects has gone on almost untamed under the globalization pressures to meet the. The human cost of development and resettlement palgrave studies in oral history bennett, o. Hari mohan mathur, distinguished professor, council for social development, new delhi, india. The human cost of development and resettlement palgrave studies in oral history kindle edition by o.
Resettlement action plan for displaced persons in badia east english abstract the lagos metropolitan development project in nigeria is a major investment in basic infrastructure towards improving the quality of life of lagos state inhabitants, in. The first of these is the tool commonly used to evaluate the financial viability of projects that cause displacement and require resettlement costbenefit analysis cba. It has, however, been less effective at addressing such political aspects of didr as differences in power among people in affected communities, the human rights of the displaced, their local autonomy and control, and their ability to affect their interactions with national institutions all of which are integral to sustainable development. The human cost of development routledge contemporary south asia series hari mohan mathur on. Book traversal links for improving outcomes in development induced displacement and resettlement projects dignified village life for the displaced up. Underfinancing emerges from the wrongheaded notion that compensation for losses is sufficient to rehabilitate a displaced economy. Displacement is commonly associated with refugees fleeing conflict, but millions of people are resettled every year in the name of development. Download city research online city, university of london. Development and displacement 2008 and resettling displaced people. This is a timely and eloquent wakeup call from the voices of the unseen and unheard casualties displaced by development. A collection of oral histories that reveal the loss of cultural continuity, identity, shifts in family responsibilities, gender roles and fractured relationships between generations that are just some.
The human cost of development and resettlement is a fine example of using oral history to empower people and to affect policy globally. The report herein was prepared for the commission as part of its information gathering activity. Displacement, resettlement, rehabilitation, reparation and development this is a working paper of the world commission on dams. Displaced is a valuable addition to the body of literature on developmentinduced displacement and resettlement didr, especially given the limited number of studies which have been published in this area over the past decade.
Displacement, resettlement, rehabilitation, reparation and development ii this is a working paper prepared for the world commission on dams as part of its informationgathering activity. He has written or edited several books on anthropology, development and resettlement, including india social development report 2008. Hari mohan mathur, displacement and resettlement in india. Development induced displacement did affects millions of people per year, a human toll that is often considered the price of development to be addressed through cerneas risk mitigation model. Since completely avoiding dislocation is sometimes difficult, the importance of carefully assessing the scale of disruption and preparation of a plan for resettlement can hardly be overemphasized. We outline the procedural human rights principles and resettlement outcomes that must be achieved in order for resettlement to be considered human rights compliant. The books main strength lies in its rigorous application of an oral history methodology to the collection and presentation of displaced peoples experiences. Improving outcomes in development induced displacement and. Around the world, development projects have led to an estimated 10 to 15 million people being displaced every year terminski 2015. Nigeria lagos metropolitan development and governance project. Written by olivia bennett, founder of the oral testimony programme of work at panos, and based on the panos archive of interviews, the book brings. Displaced people of megadevelopment projects may find it difficult to adapt and reestablish themselves in the host community and, as a consequence, feel marginalized and discriminated against from political, economic, and cultural perspectives. Economic perspectives on resettlement and rehabilitation.
The inadequacy of the risk mitigation model for the. At present, mining, financiers and governments are externalizing displacement costs onto the weakest party, the. The human cost of development and resettlement, which explores the socioeconomic, political and cultural dimensions of involuntary migration and resettlement among peoples in botswana, namibia, lesotho, kenya, india and pakistan. The object of this paper is to present mininginduced displacement and resettlement midr as a highly diverse global socioeconomic issue occurring in all regions of the world, as a human rights issue, and as a source of challenges to public international law and and institutions providing humanitarian assistance. The model, by its very name, seeks to mitigate the extent of did and the negative effects thereof. Authors olivia bennett and christopher mcdowell use individual stories collected between 1997 and 2003 to convey the suffering caused by development created involuntary resettlement in kenya. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Developmentinduced displacement is a social problem affecting multiple levels of human organization, from tribal and village. The causes, consequences, and challenges of development induced displacement by w. Development induced displacement and resettlement didr occurs when people are forced to leave their homes and or land as a result of development. A powerful book that seeks to address the absence of voice in the resettlement debate, it draws upon an extensive archive of vivid firsthand accounts by the displaced themselves, gathered by panos london and partners in africa and asia. In view of the foregoing, the government of the republic of zambia has come up with guidelines which will provide a mechanism for dealing with idps.
Resettlement and impact assessment points of intersection. The human cost of development and resettlement displacement is commonly associated with refugees fleeing conflict, but millions of people are resettled every year in the name of development and progress. This subset of forced migration has been historically associated with the construction of dams for hydroelectric power and irrigation but is also the result of various development projects such as mining, agriculture, the creation of military. And while it focuses on the voices of the displaced, it also benefits from the contributions of dr christopher mcdowell of londons city university, who has been central to the continuing research and. Mcdowell, christopher and bennett, olivia 2012 displaced. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The human cost of development and resettlement palgrave studies in oral history. Displaced the human cost of development and resettlement o.
Nigeria lagos metropolitan development and governance. Frank vanclay faculty of spatial sciences, department of cultural geography, university of groningen, groningen, the netherlands abstract while the world bank safeguard policies and international finance corporation performance. Development, displacement and rehabiliation economic and. A muchneeded contribution, this is sure to become a major work in the field of development studies. Dams, displacement and the human cost of development youth. Economic perspectives on resettlement and rehabilitation sangeeta goyal what constitutes adequate and appropriate resettlement and rehabilitation of people displaced by development projects has been the subject of considerable debate.
Courtland robinson the brookings institution sais project on internal. We also consider how human rights are addressed in the. The displaced as victims of development smitu kothari efforts at minimising displacement or improving resettlement will only be marginal, palliative and temporary if they are not contextualised in a wider sociopolitical context three contentions support the argument. Save up to 80% by choosing the etextbook option for isbn. With vivid realism, these voices bring alive the terrible trauma and human costs so prevalent with displacement and forced resettlement. May 16, 2012 displaced the human cost of development and resettlement posted on may 16, 2012. The views, conclusion, and recommendations are not intended to represent the views of the commission. A powerful book that seeks to address the absence of voice in the resettlement debate, it draws upon an extensive archive of vivid firsthand accounts by the displaced themselves, gathered by. Displaced the human cost of development and resettlement posted on may 16, 2012. Jan 04, 2019 it is prudent to apply a human rightbased approach to development processes to safeguard human rights of displaced people, so that they could escape from further impoverishment and also benefit from development interventions that have deprived them of their human rights. A human rights based approach to project induced displacement. Displaced the human cost of development and resettlement by o. The human cost of development and resettlement palgrave studies in oral history 2012 by bennett, o.
In involuntarily resettlement literature, such rights are labelled entitlements or as development opportunities. Perceived discrimination of displaced people in development. Displacement and resettlement in india the human cost of. Panos london marks the international day of sharing life stories on may 16, by announcing the publication of displaced. The human cost of development and resettlement apo.
535 290 181 425 64 1554 503 1122 351 25 996 280 567 890 1230 1445 568 512 1521 986 784 207 801 478 55 1171 810 1080 1350 1470 1060 311 1065 1250