Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The liberal government that signed the accord in 1997 ratified it in parliament in 2002. Influenced by the outcome of a purely domestic costbenefit analysis involving reductions in ozonedepleting chemicals, the united states enthusiastically supported the montreal protocol. The kyoto protocol is a global treaty to reduce the emissions of carbon dioxide, co2. Montreal protocol in 1973, at the university of california, irvine, mario molina suggested to his advisor f. Both involve global risks created by diverse nations, and both. If further measures are to materialise accelerated phase out of hcfcs additional climate benefits could be reaped, possibly as much as taking out again the entire reduction potential of kyoto.
The benefit to climate achieved by the montreal protocol alone at present greatly exceeds the initial target of the kyoto protocol. Montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer with annex. Sherwood rowland that cfcs could have some lingering effect in the earths atmosphere. Montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer montreal protocol the kyoto protocol is set up with its common short name, instead of kyoto protocol to the united nations framework convention on climate change, whereas the almost as common montreal protocol is not. Dubai pathway on hfcs to work within the montreal protocol to an hfc. Article of the fccc, the noncompliance procedure of the montreal protocol served as the model and the experience gained in its application since 1991 was taken into account.
International protocols regarding global climate change. The case of reduced cfc emissions and the montreal protocol, 63 j. On top of that, the montreal protocol did more for climate change than kyoto did 10 gigatonnes carbon dioxide equivalent gt co2e, the unit of avoided co2 emissions avoided per year in 2010, which is 5 times the annual reduction target for the kyoto protocol over 20082012. The montreal protocol the montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer is an international treaty designed to protect the ozone layer by phasing out the production of numerous substances believed to be responsible for ozone depletion. Montreal last november in the expectation, or perhaps faint hope, of a stronger kyoto protocol protocol capable of addressing climate change beyond 2012, the question again arose as to whether a system with stronger economic enforcement mechanisms would be legally viable under the current international economic system. The goal is for annex 1 developed countries plus economies in transition to reduce their aggregate anthropogenic carbon dioxide equivalent emissions by at least 5% below 1990 levels in the. Montreal protocol vs kyoto protocol the montreal protocol, which was originally established in 1987, was created as a result of the finding of the ozone hole over antarctica by rowland and molina.
The rise and fall of the kyoto protocol climate change as a political process abstract. To achieve a global phaseout of hfcs, greenpeace seeks cooperation between the montreal protocol and the unfccc and whatever legal instruments arise from the copenhagen meeting in 2009 and its kyoto protocol. Further information on alternatives to ozone depleting substances the text of this report is composed in times new roman. These countries have also ratified the london, copenhagen, montreal, and beijing amendments.
The international treaties for the protection of the ozone layer and the global climate are closely related. Abstract the emission limits in the kyoto protocol are too generous. This research focuses on climate change as a political process. An economic assessment of the kyoto protocol using the. The kyoto protocol, which entered into force on 16 february 2005, commits developed countries to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases by 5% in 2012 compared to 1990. Concluded at montreal on 16 sep tember 1987 authentic texts. Compared with kyotos base year, 1990, emissions have already risen 28 percent.
Parties present and voting means parties present and casting an affirmative or negative vote. The kyoto protocol is an international treaty which extends the 1992 united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc that commits state parties to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, based on the scientific consensus that part one global warming is occurring and part two it is extremely likely that humanmade co 2 emissions have predominantly caused it. The kyoto protocol represents a milestone in climate policy. Sunstein abstract over the last thirty years, climate change and depletion of the ozone layer have been widely believed to be the worlds largest environmental problems. Jacoby abstract under the kyoto protocol, the worlds wealthier countries assumed binding commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. But an extraordinarily successful agreement, the montreal protocol, has served largely to eliminate the production and use. Not only has the montreal protocol for the protection of the ozone layer served as a useful example in developing the international climate regime, but policies pursued in both issue areas influence each other. Cass sunstein compares the relative ease with which the united states adopted the montreal protocol against its rejection of the kyoto protocol to conclude that the perceived costs versus perceived benefits of climate change action will have to significantly improve before the united states adopts an international climate change treaty.
How not to repeat the mistakes of the kyoto protocol. R32, r600a, ethane hc170 or r170, and a blend of hydrocar. Greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide co 2, methane ch 4, nitrous oxide n 2 o, perfluorocarbons pfcs. Montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer. Linkages between the montreal and kyoto protocols enhancing. Lessons from kyoto the paris accord provides its members with more flexibility than the earlier kyoto protocol, an argument for those who want the united states to remain in the deal. The montreal protocol is an international treaty designed to protect the ozone layer by phasing out the production of numerous substances that are responsible for ozone. Convention on climate change unfccc and the kyoto protocol by. The 1987 montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer is a. While the poor countries want the protocol retained and improved, those. The montreal protocol is an international treaty governing the protection of stratospheric ozone, originally signed in 1987 and substantially amended in 1990 and 1992. Kyoto protocol, should aim to phaseout hfcs worldwide as soon as possible but certainly no later than the global ods phaseout regime.
Unfccc, kyoto protocol, montreal protocol, pollution. The montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer, as it is called in full, and its amendments are international treaties requiring that countries end production. Just why has the kyoto protocol proved such a hot issue in copenhagen. In effect, the kyoto protocol requires the worlds developed countries to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 5% from 1990 levels by. It is the first legally binding global agreement to cut greenhouse gases. Influenced by the very different outcome of costbenefit analyses for reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, the united states aggressively opposed the kyoto. The kyoto protocol was adopted in 1997 and it became law on february 16, 2005. Montreal protocol and its implications for climate change.
Ods are regulated under the montreal protocol, while hfcs are currently included among the basket of six ghgs2 regulated under the kyoto protocol to the united nations framework convention on climate change hereafter referred to as the kyoto protocol. A brief summary of two international provisions which aim to recuperate the environment from the deteriorating effects of various gaseous compunds. In 2008, the only nonparties were andorra, holy see, iraq, san marino, timor leste. Kyoto protocol officially took effect and it focuses on the structure of the kyoto protocol. Kyoto protocols shortcomings the canadian encyclopedia. Montreal, 17 september 2007 international efforts to safeguard earths climate and protect the ozone layer are mutually supportive, say the united nations top climate change and environment officials. However, even if the kyoto protocol works exactly as intended, global emissions and atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases will continue to rise. They discovered that chlorofluorocarbons cfcs were the culprit of the ozone depletion. After an exhaustive sevenyear fight, the treaty came into force earlier this year, and its.
The kyoto protocol was adopted as the first addition to the united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc, an international treaty that committed its signatories to develop national programs to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases. The montreal protocol is a treaty to try to protect the ozone layer by reducing the using of ozone depleting materials such as chlorofluorocarbons. Canada was active in the negotiations that led to the kyoto protocol in 1997. Request pdf linkages between the montreal and kyoto protocols enhancing synergies between protecting the ozone layer and the global climate the. The montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer. Importance of the montreal protocol the 1987 montreal protocol restricting the use of ozonedepleting substances has helped both to reduce global warming and to protect the ozone layer. Montreal protocol means the montreal protocol on substances that deplete the ozone layer, adopted in montreal on 16 september 1987 and as subsequently adjusted and amended.
An international agreement that aims to reduce carbon dioxide emissions and the presence of greenhouse gases. Briefing note on legal aspects in the context of hfc. The kyoto protocol was an early attempt at collective action. This week in montreal, the stars of the world environmental movement will gather to celebrate their greatest victory consummation of the kyoto protocol and to plan their next steps in the war against global warming. Protocol led to more reductions in greenhouse gases than what is foreseen under the kyoto protocol. Terms and impacts of the kyoto protocol parliament of. The kyoto protocol is a protocol to the united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc or fccc, aimed at fighting global warming.
Arabic, chinese, english, french, russian and spanish. The kyoto protocol, also known as the kyoto accord, is an international treaty among industrialized nations that sets mandatory limits on greenhouse gas emissions. The kyoto protocol ratification will be open for signing on 16 march 1998, in new york. Resolving conflicts between multilateral environmental. Background analysis for the kyoto protocol oecd workshop oecd headquarters, paris, 1718 september 1998. The united states firmly rejects the agreement, with unanimous bipartisan opposition to its ratification. These accords binds the signing nations to reduce carbon emissions based upon the hypothesis that co2 is. Climate change, the kyoto protocol, and the world trade. The kyoto protocol is an agreement to try to reduce pollution of greenhouse gasses that is believed to be causing global warming. Although the research was based on literature, rowl. The unfccc is an international environmental treaty with the goal of achieving stabilization of greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that would minimize dangerous. The kyoto protocol is an international agreement on the reduction of greenhous gas emissions and on mechanisms aimed at cutting the costs of reducing emissions, in order to address possible changes in the climate. The kyoto protocol spurred the creation of the european union emissions trading scheme, and many people foresee the growth.
An international transaction log, a softwarebased accounting system, ensures the secure transfer of emission reduction units erus between countries. The different climate change protocols operating in the international system 3. The kyoto protocol has now been ratified by 180 nations,7. Difference between montreal protocol and kyoto conference. The kyoto protocol is the proposal to reduce carbon dioxide, and the montreal protocol is to protect the ozone which is being depleted by chlorofluorocarbons. The kyoto protocol is an international agreement, which for the first time establishes legally binding limits for 37 industrialized countries on emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse. The importance of the montreal protocol in protecting climate pnas. This paper gives an overview of the many ways in which both treaty systems. Montreal and kyoto protocol free download as powerpoint presentation. The implications to the montreal protocol of the inclusion of hfcs. Canadas kyoto target was a 6% total reduction in greenhouse gas ghg emissions by 2012, compared to 1990 levels of 461 megatonnes mt government of canada gc 1994.
1475 245 8 1428 207 1179 604 308 18 1059 362 864 1450 864 294 819 771 711 1165 1119 312 607 462 959 378 747 1179 554 130 1289 874 737 724 1471 695 1298 1172 520 1378 761 1100 843 284 171